
It all started because Jesus walked by the seaside early that morning. Those first disciples were about to get the shock of their lives. That morning, four fishermen were completing an unfulfilling night’s work and hoping for better things the next night. By evening of that same day, they had left their businesses and their families to follow Jesus. But the accounts differ.
Matthew 4:18-22 One day as Jesus was walking along the shore of the Sea of Galilee, he saw two brothers—Simon, also called Peter, and Andrew—throwing a net into the water, for they fished for a living. Jesus called out to them, “Come, follow me, and I will show you how to fish for people!” And they left their nets at once and followed him.
A little farther up the shore he saw two other brothers, James and John, sitting in a boat with their father, Zebedee, repairing their nets. And he called them to come, too. They immediately followed him, leaving the boat and their father behind.
Luke 5:1-11 One day as Jesus was preaching on the shore of the Sea of Galilee, great crowds pressed in on him to listen to the word of God. He noticed two empty boats at the water’s edge, for the fishermen had left them and were washing their nets. Stepping into one of the boats, Jesus asked Simon, its owner, to push it out into the water. So he sat in the boat and taught the crowds from there.
When he had finished speaking, he said to Simon, “Now go out where it is deeper, and let down your nets to catch some fish.”
“Master,” Simon replied, “we worked hard all last night and didn’t catch a thing. But if you say so, I’ll let the nets down again.” And this time their nets were so full of fish they began to tear! A shout for help brought their partners in the other boat, and soon both boats were filled with fish and on the verge of sinking.
When Simon Peter realized what had happened, he fell to his knees before Jesus and said, “Oh, Lord, please leave me—I’m such a sinful man.” For he was awestruck by the number of fish they had caught, as were the others with him. His partners, James and John, the sons of Zebedee, were also amazed.
Jesus replied to Simon, “Don’t be afraid! From now on you’ll be fishing for people!” And as soon as they landed, they left everything and followed Jesus.
John 1:35-51 The following day John was again standing with two of his disciples. As Jesus walked by, John looked at him and declared, “Look! There is the Lamb of God!” When John’s two disciples heard this, they followed Jesus.
Jesus looked around and saw them following. “What do you want?” he asked them.
They replied, “Rabbi” (which means “Teacher”), “where are you staying?”
“Come and see,” he said. It was about four o’clock in the afternoon when they went with him to the place where he was staying, and they remained with him the rest of the day.
Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, was one of these men who heard what John said and then followed Jesus. Andrew went to find his brother, Simon, and told him, “We have found the Messiah” (which means “Christ”).
Then Andrew brought Simon to meet Jesus. Looking intently at Simon, Jesus said, “Your name is Simon, son of John—but you will be called Cephas” (which means “Peter”).
Four different Gospel writers have four different accounts of Jesus calling his first disciples. I have omitted Mark’s account because it is so similar to that of Matthew. But which one is the correct account? The answer is all of them. John was a partner or at least a colleague of Andrew and Peter in the fishing business, so they likely told him the story of Andrew introducing Peter to Jesus. That doesn’t preclude Jesus later requesting Peter to push out from land so that Jesus could sit in Peter’s boat and preach without being trampled by the crowds. And if James and John were sitting repairing nets, they would certainly have responded eagerly to Peter’s frantic calls for help as his overburdened nets threatened to sink his boat.
How frequently do eyewitnesses agree? An AI internet search reveals the following: Eyewitnesses rarely agree on all the details of an event. Studies and legal experience show that when multiple people witness the same incident, they usually provide slightly different versions, largely due to variations in perspective, attention, memory, and cognitive filtering.
Cold Case Christianity
Here is a breakdown of how many witnesses agree, based on psychological research and legal statistics:
- Rare Absolute Agreement: It is almost unheard of for multiple witnesses to agree on every single detail, even in simple scenarios.
- Contamination (71% Agreement): A major risk in multiple-witness scenarios is “co-witness contamination,” where witnesses discuss the event afterward. Research indicates that 71% of witnesses may change their accounts to include false information that their co-witnesses mentioned.
- High Error Rate (1 in 3): The American Psychological Association estimates that roughly one in three (33%) eyewitnesses make an erroneous identification.
- Multiple Wrong Witnesses (38% of Cases): In cases of wrongful conviction, studies have found that in 38% of cases, multiple eyewitnesses wrongly identified the same innocent person.
- The “3-Witness Rule” (General Rule of Thumb): In practice, if three different witnesses tell the exact same, perfect story, it can actually be a sign of contamination or coaching, as normal human perception is too varied for perfect consensus.
Cold Case Christianity +4
Factors Affecting Agreement:
- Stress and Violence: High-stress events, such as violent crimes, lead to less accurate, inconsistent, and lower-quality recall.
- Post-Event Discussion: 86% of eyewitnesses discuss the event with others, which can align their stories—but often by creating a shared false memory rather than confirming the truth.
- Time and Memory Decay: Memory fades rapidly immediately following an event, causing more discrepancies as time passes.
ScienceDirect.com +1
Conclusion:
While having multiple witnesses is generally better than one, it is normal and expected for them to disagree on specific details. When they do agree, it is sometimes due to memory contamination rather than accurate, independent recollection.

So, four different writers vary in their descriptions, but the one salient fact is this: Jesus called four Galilean fishermen as his first disciples, and they left everything behind to follow him. If these men had regrets, they never spoke about it. There were some questions, though. When a rich young ruler turned away after Jesus advised him to sell everything and follow him, Peter spoke up. Peter said, “We’ve left our homes to follow you.”
“Yes,” Jesus replied, “and I assure you that everyone who has given up house or wife or brothers or parents or children, for the sake of the Kingdom of God, will be repaid many times over in this life, and will have eternal life in the world to come.” (Luke 18:28-30)
When Jesus spoke, these men heard God calling them so compulsively that they felt they must follow Jesus, even though it cost them everything-wealth, standing in the community, safety, and security. Eventually, eleven of the disciples died as martyrs while John was the only one to die of old age, and even he had been boiled in oil in an attempt to kill him.
What kept these men going? Why were they willing to commit so completely? Saint Paul would later give an answer in Romans 8:35-39. Can anything ever separate us from Christ’s love? Does it mean he no longer loves us if we have trouble or calamity, or are persecuted, or hungry, or destitute, or in danger, or threatened with death? (As the Scriptures say, “For your sake we are killed every day; we are being slaughtered like sheep.”) No, despite all these things, overwhelming victory is ours through Christ, who loved us.
And I am convinced that nothing can ever separate us from God’s love. Neither death nor life, neither angels nor demons, neither our fears for today nor our worries about tomorrow—not even the powers of hell can separate us from God’s love. No power in the sky above or in the earth below—indeed, nothing in all creation will ever be able to separate us from the love of God that is revealed in Christ Jesus our Lord.
Those fishermen followed Jesus and never looked back. If you could interview Andrew or Peter or James or John today, they would simply say, “It was worth it! We lost earth to gain heaven.” Today, what choice will you make? Will you follow Jesus, losing earth to gain heaven?
PRAYER: Father God, thank You for loving us and caring for us. Lord, please speak to the hearts of all who read these words, that they may know You as Savior and Lord. In the mighty and precious Name of King Jesus. Amen.









